I have just resolved an issue that I thought someone else might run into in the future, so I'm posting it to the list for future googlers.

Problem Symptoms:
System:
Solution:
The cron.log error indicates that the problem is located somewhere within the PAM stack, which is preventing crond  from launching a shell owned by the otrs user. The system in question is using /etc/security/access.conf to limit login access to the server. (Useful for limiting login access when the system uses some form of centralized authentication.) Other required PAM modules may also interfere. In this case adding a line to permit the otrs user login access via cron:

+ : otrs : cron crond

or less secure

+ : ALL : cron crond